Why New York City is so Huge
10:58
597,936
Reddit
Three reasons why this city became so huge
Sign up to Morning Brew for FREE: cen.yt/morningbrewjohnnyharris
Thanks to Morning Brew for sponsoring this video.
I launched a Patreon. If you want to support my videos, head here: www.patreon.com/johnnyharris
Tom Fox makes custom music for my videos. He's amazing.
linktr.ee/tomfoxmusic126
For anyone who likes smarter travel, Iz and I started a company: brighttrip.com/?ref=5
Subscribe to my channel: goo.gl/1U8Zy7
My Instagram: instagram.com/johnny.harris/
Facebook: facebook.com/JohnnyHarris
Tom Fox made the music for this video: tfbeats.com/
I also get music from Artlist: bit.ly/2XfAE6C
And Music Bed share.mscbd.fm/johnnywharris
Iz's Channel: uzload.info
We sell our drone prints: backdropstock.com/collections/iz-harris
And we send an email once a month with a Spotify playlist. Sign up if that sounds cool: www.izharris.com/newsletter
Gear I use: www.izharris.com/gear-guide
Camera: geni.us/xK9Al
Favorite Lens: geni.us/VrAWNG
Second Favorite Lens: geni.us/Hcgdrb
Travel Tripod: geni.us/Sf0bA
Drone: geni.us/glWJhq
Johnny Harris is a filmmaker and journalist. He currently is based in Washington, DC, reporting on interesting trends and stories domestically and around the globe. Johnny's visual style blends motion graphics with cinematic videography to create content that explains complex issues in relatable ways. He holds a BA in international relations from Brigham Young University and an MA in international peace and conflict resolution from American University.
Vox: www.vox.com/authors/johnny-harris
Spotlight: byupoliticalscienceblog.com/2016/03/09/alumnus-spotlight-johnny-harris/
XYNTEO Interview: xynteo.com/insights/latest/power-storytelling-johnny-harris
Bonnier Talk: vimeo.com/232416596
Neiman Lab: tinyurl.com/ybjbvb7h
Emmy Nomination: tinyurl.com/y9gjgel2
Storytelling Tips: chase.be/blog/5-storytelling-tips-by-johnny-harris/
Craig Adams Podcast: open.spotify.com/episode/4cS0vEIt2p69Wva6BnXGdR
So Money Podcast: tinyurl.com/ycjbl4p5

Fikrlar
  • Johnny Harris
    Johnny Harris

    Hey Friends. Corrections/clarifications: 1. yes indeed the Erie Canal was built way after the british left. I should have made that clear. 2. "Bronx" isn't dutch. i must have been thinking "Harlem" and should have double checked. Whoops 3. (Old) York has lots to do with water and regularly floods (thank you all for telling me about that. I had no idea!) 4. I wont apologize for misspellings cuz being pedantic about typos is not a good use of our time here on earth. im dyslexic and will mispell things until the day I die. If you can't handle it, maybe best not to watch my videos? 5. k im done. Im doing my best with these vids and sometimes mis things here and there. that will likely always happen as long as I don't have a team to help fact check and comb thru everything I write. Hope you learned a bit about the growth of NYC! -Johnny

    • Chloé Elimam
      Chloé Elimam

      I LOVE your videos and I am making a comic for a class of mine because I got really into learning about the Delta Works project in the Netherlands from your video! To people that are upset about the typo, I don't find misspelling offensive at all. People make mistakes and we all know what he meant to write and say. He made a beautiful video and tries to learn about some really cool stuff and share it with us and does so in a really entertainin way. I'm not gonna get upset over an extra E when I can see all the work being done right infront of me. Have a little empathy friends.

    • Abcde
      Abcde

      @richlisola1 He sed speling is pedantik

    • richlisola1
      richlisola1

      Dude. Are you dyslexic? Staten Island is not called Stanten Island. You actually edited this and left that in?

    • Abcde
      Abcde

      @Meghan Smith Hey Meghan the Bronx is Dutch because it was named after Bronck's River where Jonas Bronck lived in the 1600's and he was Dutch

    • Shirish Kadam
      Shirish Kadam

      Loved the video

  • Minco Jürgens
    Minco Jürgens

    Imagine wearing a helmet when driving a bike... (I live in The Netherlands) Also, nice video!

  • mr_noob
    mr_noob

    aren't u that voc guy .. yeah thatd where i saw u..

  • Michael Jones
    Michael Jones

    I dunno about rest of y'all but I find Johnnys voice so relaxing.. thanks for the content!

  • Amit Hattimare
    Amit Hattimare

    That's called dedication towards content creation. Wow. Keep it up.

  • something craft
    something craft

    London is bigger than New York

  • Russell St.Martin
    Russell St.Martin

    Whoa I always thought they built this city on rock n' roll

  • Varun
    Varun

    4th factor: Geography- It's relative proximity to Europe caused it to flourish. 5th factor: It being within a wealthy & powerful nation called United States of America. Somewhere within the nation, a concentrated powerhouse had to exist.

  • Dutch Will
    Dutch Will

    What building is that on 6:42?

  • Pushpdant Sharma
    Pushpdant Sharma

    Ok now this is breaking so many layers .... The name in the map of gta 4 based on new york city for the manhattan Island is " Algonquin " which is derived from the actual natives algo quin people . Wow 🤯 .

  • Joseph Leonard
    Joseph Leonard

    New York is basically the capital of the world

  • Jay Cup
    Jay Cup

    What New Yorkers will never admit is that they felt extremely threatened that rebuilt Chicago (the 2nd city)was the fastest growing city in the world in the 19th century. And becoming the most important city in America. That they annexed Brooklyn so this combination could combat Chicago economically.

  • foxbasealpha
    foxbasealpha

    5:19 Erie Canal, not Eerie Canal, unless you are traveling on it during Halloween.

  • tudorjason
    tudorjason

    I would have preferred New Amsterdam to stick and to be around today.

  • Samesh Maharaj
    Samesh Maharaj

    New York City will be the next Detroit.

  • Warbler
    Warbler

    Laughs in Pearl River Delta

  • Trigger Random
    Trigger Random

    The Philippines would be the 2nd new york in asia if It weren't for Corruption

  • ola jong
    ola jong

    Video- Why New York is so Huge Me- Why New York Rats are so Huge and plentiful

  • Connecticut Ball
    Connecticut Ball

    Did you quit your job at Vox?

  • Tomerican
    Tomerican

    Love the video, but Johnny -- how could the British have used the eerie canal if it was finished in 1825?

  • loaded 21
    loaded 21

    My City is bigger than new York I live in Texas

  • Rares
    Rares

    The city was actully named in honour of the Duke of York and not directly named after the City of York in the UK.

  • xSoccerFreak7
    xSoccerFreak7

    I feel like more immigrants were exploited than entrepreneurs but that’s just my opinion I guess

  • Teegan
    Teegan

    I love your videos

  • Arin
    Arin

    Whenever I see old footage from 1900s or before, it makes me sad thinking nobody is alive anymore. Makes me appreciate life even more.

  • richlisola1
    richlisola1

    Stealing sugar huh? How about acquiring and making.

  • Roland Tiiroja
    Roland Tiiroja

    Literally eating New York Pizza atm in Estonia

  • Rob Just
    Rob Just

    Show the real NYC. You’re so closed minded.

  • thenort13
    thenort13

    "I like to look at maps." Jup, that's me.

  • Daphne Parkhill
    Daphne Parkhill

    this guy said stanten island im dead

  • Richard Wills-Woodward
    Richard Wills-Woodward

    New York - clue is in the name. London's metropolitan area is spread over an area only slightly smaller than New York's and but New York's central area is slightly smaller than central London. You could also make this video about Tokyo. Tall buildings make size deceptively larger to your eye when the area of a square can be the same. The one with tall buildings is perceived as larger. Looks impressive, no denying that, but NYC is no longer a long way ahead of others, but merely in a pack, albeit at the top of that pack but not the way it was just 30 years ago. Worth noting, the largest cities in area are in Japan and the English speaking countries of the USA, UK, Australia (but low population relative to size) due to suburban living spreading over stupid size areas. China goes up, but not out as far as one might imagine. Population wise, nothing touches Tokyo - they are in a league of their own!

  • cmair77
    cmair77

    I don’t mind the honest mistakes, not a big deal

  • S U
    S U

    Europeans "stole" sugar? Lol.

  • Blowson Melissa
    Blowson Melissa

    I want to appreciate DR GODFATHER for the restoration of my marriage with his spell casting after 2years of separation with my husband, with the help of DR GODFATHER spell my husband return home and now we are happily together for good,once again thanks DR GODFATHER, He also cure all kinds of spell casting and sickness such as: 1 LOVE SPELL 2 GOOD JOB SPELL 3 FRUIT OF THE WORN 4 HIV CURE 5 FIBROIDS CURE 6 HERPES CURE 7 DIABETES CURE 8 PROMOTION SPELL 8 LOTTER SPELL Contact Dr Godfather for your help or WhatsApp him +2347062606817 or email drgodfatherspellcaster1@gmail.com

  • Becky George
    Becky George

    HOW DR GODFATHER FIX UP MY RELATIONSHIP I have been in a relationship for 3 years now and we have been very happy together so we where about to get married and it was the happiest time in my life but something happen he was not happy about the marriage and it get me worry 4 weeks before our weeding I find out that he has someone else and which he also promised marriage as well, 3 days latter he came back and told me that he has cancelled the weeding i was not happy with him because of the change at once and make me want to kill myself, i don't eat or drink for 2 good day because i have no hope of living, a friend of my came to visit me to see how we are preparing for the weeding and I told her everything that happen she told me not to worry that she has someone to fix things out for me she give me Dr Godfather contact which i immediately contacted him and he ask for my details which i did and ask me to pay some amount of money to cast the spell i believed him and did all that he ask, a week latter my Ex came back and beg me to forgve him and even bought me a new car just to make me happy please if there is any one of you out there that need this type of help please contact this great Dr on his Email address drgodfatherspellcaster1@gmail.com or whatspp him on +2347062606817 this is how God use this man to restore my relationship back in just a week and 4 days He also cast spell such as : 1) Love Spells 2) Lost Love Spells 3) Divorce Spells 4) Marriage Spells 5) Binding Spells 6) Breakup Spells 7) Banish a past Lover. 8.) You want to be promoted in your office 9) want to satisfy your lover 10) Death spell 11)Gay/Lesbian Love spell 12)Money spell 13) court case spell 14)celebrity spell 15) politics spell 16) Exams spell 17)Beauty spell 18)Good-luck spell 19) Do as i say spell

  • juncchi ramen
    juncchi ramen

    Glad to watch you bite size videos again.

  • scottembler
    scottembler

    Say Staten Island again.

  • Funny company
    Funny company

    Americans are so self centered Them: why does New York feel like the epicenter of the world? LOL

  • Joe Caselnova
    Joe Caselnova

    The greatest city on Earth. I wouldn’t rather live anywhere else.

    • PinoyAbnoy
      PinoyAbnoy

      @Joe Caselnova what part of nyc youre from

    • Joe Caselnova
      Joe Caselnova

      @PinoyAbnoy You clearly have never been here. I’m not rich by any means and live very good here.

    • PinoyAbnoy
      PinoyAbnoy

      the greatest for the rich only?

  • John
    John

    When Jonny said water I instantly thought of the last avatar intro

  • bark
    bark

    This video is so good, yet so bad. Please do better research or have someone who’s knowledgeable on the subject matter help you edit your script.

  • Stryder
    Stryder

    Hundreds of years later they still call it "New" York.

  • Dung Nguyen
    Dung Nguyen

    cool stuff, thanks that NYC

  • MCoupeMike
    MCoupeMike

    so many false statements, you should delete the video. Most people are not going to reference the comments for corrections

  • Abcde
    Abcde

    4:47 the gratuitous anti-white statements begin. Indians DID own land, but not individually. Tribes owned land, and they were extremely territorial about it, tribes were constantly fighting over territory. That's why the Manhattan Indians could sell land to the Dutch. Never mind the fact that they lived in Jersey.

  • frostyguy1989
    frostyguy1989

    ~ And it was New York, New York She took your heart away from mine And it was New York, New York And she poisoned your sweet mind ~ I have no idea where this song came from, but it's been stuck in my head for months.

  • gaudetjaja
    gaudetjaja

    As a Dutch person I vehemently despise America and anything it stands for but I´ll gladly make an exception for new york city. What a great city, I am grateful that I had the chance to visit it before coronavirus.

  • Adrian Ritchie
    Adrian Ritchie

    So easy and fun to learn from your style of filmmaking 🙏🏼

  • spqr1945
    spqr1945

    More mistakes you make, more comments you get, and it is good for youtube algorythm. Some bloggers even do mistakes on purpose.

  • bluecoldchocolatesalt
    bluecoldchocolatesalt

    Dude. You gotta put that helmet properly on the child's head!

  • Sandra Hoffmann
    Sandra Hoffmann

    great video! Thanks for your wonderful work! keep going!

  • Rohan Banerjee
    Rohan Banerjee

    I kinda feel inspired after watching this😃... awesome video JH

  • 3506Dodge
    3506Dodge

    Cities don't grow, or not grow, for material reasons. New York City didn't grow because of the Erie Canal. The Erie Canal was created because of New York City. The City's culture made possible political and financial interaction that simply did not happen elsewhere. NYC's unusually open and diverse cultural explains its growth. All the things John mentions here are effects, not causes. Culture is the cause.

  • 3506Dodge
    3506Dodge

    Metro NYC has about 15 million people.

  • Aaliyah Joseph
    Aaliyah Joseph

    Also, a video on Philadelphia, which is arguably way more complex than New York, would be really interesting!

  • Aaliyah Joseph
    Aaliyah Joseph

    Maybe for the next video you could go into more detail about how slavery/unpaid labor allowed new york to become the economic epicenter it is. I think you touch on it when you reference all the migrants to New York but??? (also I’m from Oregon too and grew up with the same complex haha)

  • Tony Mancuso
    Tony Mancuso

    There is so many factual errors in this video.

  • Tomis Kroondyk
    Tomis Kroondyk

    Risk takers..... sounds like they just wanna exploit people and get rich.

  • Ferdinand Cesarano
    Ferdinand Cesarano

    "Stanton Island"?

  • KC _101
    KC _101

    NYC is tiny compared to Tokyo and Beijing.

  • Ciara Hynes
    Ciara Hynes

    Very similar to London, that's all I was thinking most of the time.

  • Saya Luthfan
    Saya Luthfan

    Dutch : lets barter maluku with my new amsterdam British : deal.

  • Antonio Kastro Carlisle De Melendez Y Tenerife
    Antonio Kastro Carlisle De Melendez Y Tenerife

    8.4 million people packed inside only 303 sq miles with manhattan just a tiny 23 sq miles yet even after living here all 35 years of my life I always find something new even in Manhattan ..it really is like a microcosm of the world and it amazed when I got older and starting reading more to find out just how many cities in this country that are way bigger than NYC in land area that is...NYC truly is a marvel and I wonder often how it's even possible.. especially manhattan

  • Ben Gully
    Ben Gully

    Hmm. The natives believed that the Dutch were leasing the land from them. They were not just ignorant natives. They understood their survival depended on their land. But definitely an informative n interesting video. 2020 will change the history of nyc

  • LUpilot2012
    LUpilot2012

    New York is nasty af

  • Zachary Gordon
    Zachary Gordon

    yo this video is full of inaccuracies! is everything you do this poorly researched and I just don't know? shame.

  • Zachary Gordon
    Zachary Gordon

    stanton island

  • Albert Morris
    Albert Morris

    What's up with the mask-for-show, Johnny? You're not in a crowd. You're alone, maybe outside! Don't let the "fear" get to you, bud.

  • Garbanzo Beans
    Garbanzo Beans

    What an absolutely disingenuous lens in which to view history from. The modern day university has absolutely destroyed actual history in the name of so called progressivism. Well done, you’ve effectively benefited from the work of our ancestors just to be entirely unappreciative of their labor.

  • Tobias Unknown
    Tobias Unknown

    Like most Americans you say "world" and mean "America". NYC was certainly not the "World's factory" in the 1800s when up until WWI the UK economy was bigger than the US. And the global economic center in the 19th century was certainly more London than NYC.

  • HARIZ HASNAN
    HARIZ HASNAN

    I really wan t go to New York. because NYC is my dream city. But now, NYC is not safe to travel there due to Corona Virus is attack United State

  • Paula Greene
    Paula Greene

    Great to visit. Not live in but amazing anyway.

  • Robert Randazzo
    Robert Randazzo

    LOL how is some random trendy taco place in midtown Manhattan the "best tacos on the east coast"? Not even the best tacos in Manhattan.

  • Eric Rotsinger
    Eric Rotsinger

    Among other misplaced dogma, that $24 was wrong.

  • Scott Baker
    Scott Baker

    Johnny - where do you find your archival footage? Do you license it, does this count as fair use, or do you just fly under the radar?

  • Tennessee Woodiel
    Tennessee Woodiel

    Would be great if the title was 'Why New York City is so Fit to Support systems of Capitalism and Colonialism." Felt a bit like a perspective guided mainly by the history of Western economics, with little attention given to the effects of those economic pursuits, nor any other contributing factors to the cultural significance of the city. This not only gives me a vibe that this wasn't thoroughly researched, it also serves to glorify the economic systems that have made the city a hostile and discriminatory environment for many inhabitants (including immigrants, which he esensentializes while attempting to celebrate them), and overlooks the many cultural, artistic, and political contributions that resistance to such inequalities have garnered within the city. Comes off as tone deaf and insignificant. Oh well.

  • Krishna Joshi
    Krishna Joshi

    So at the end we came to knew that NEWYORK was originally valued at 24dollars hmmmmmmmm WTF 😂😂😂😂

  • sugar plumchum
    sugar plumchum

    I'm so glad you have subtitles!!!

  • Per-Ola Mjömark
    Per-Ola Mjömark

    Bronx is a Dutch name? I thought that Bronx was named after the Swedish immigrant Jonas Bronck? Or is it disputed? 4:50

  • ZuSa the Demigod
    ZuSa the Demigod

    The promised land of NY

  • Murray Heymann
    Murray Heymann

    There once was a Dutchman who got so good at water, he learned how to fly...

  • Emeric's Timelapse
    Emeric's Timelapse

    Amazing video! I was glad to see some of my timelapse videos in it :D

  • Sean Steinberg
    Sean Steinberg

    You still dress and look like a Oregonian. Clothes you would climb mt hood with and have a nice brunch in the morning. You look like a lame and sound worse

  • Izzy N
    Izzy N

    Wait you guys are friends with Sara Dietschy??

  • GuliversTravelocity
    GuliversTravelocity

    Epicenter of the world though...?

  • VegetableFRIES
    VegetableFRIES

    This video makes me proud of being a New Yorker.

  • qopoy dnon
    qopoy dnon

    New York was named after the Duke of York, not the city of York, contrary to popular belief

  • Hoo Stone
    Hoo Stone

    Coz you haven't been to Tokyo yet~

    • qopoy dnon
      qopoy dnon

      the Brooklyn Promenade and not see ships at pier is disorienting.

  • KelZ X
    KelZ X

    Subscribed!

  • Alex
    Alex

    NYC is so Huge L.A Hold my size

  • Fatima Bamba
    Fatima Bamba

    Wow, this comment section... yall are real passionate about new york lmfao. As a native new yorker, allow me to say! it ain't that great! awesome video johnny!

  • Apolitical Being
    Apolitical Being

    I love cinematography and the editing of your videos. They are so beautiful and a delight to watch.

  • Hayden Jay
    Hayden Jay

    This is a beautiful video. Well done!

  • bcvbb hyui
    bcvbb hyui

    As a Midwesterner, seeing the Erie Canal spelled “Eerie Canal” bothers me more than I’d like to admit.

  • Filippo Montanini
    Filippo Montanini

    I didn't think that I could've love New York City more than I do, but after watching this video I'm on a totally another level of love for this city

  • Joseph Adams
    Joseph Adams

    Loved the city. Still do, even though it doesn't love me back. Would love to make one more trip to visit there before I die, though at present that seems unlikely.

  • Tasnia Islam
    Tasnia Islam

    $24?

  • Dává to Smysl
    Dává to Smysl

    AD/AD/little content/SPONSOR/AD/little content/AD/AD/SPONSOR Like seriously?!

  • Organic Life
    Organic Life

    Take your mask off sheep!!!

  • Pascal van Gestel
    Pascal van Gestel

    America is New York Netherlands is Amsterdam

Keyingisi